A distinctive outline, a quiet colour palette or a small pattern detail may be what stays with you. Try describing an interesting item in a few simple words. These observations are more useful for understanding your preferences than trying to choose a single “correct” style immediately.
Choose a few cards that share a colour, item type or pattern style. Differences between similar designs are easier to see in a small group. Then change one criterion and explore another selection. This keeps the comparison focused and helps you notice details without mixing too many impressions.
A first impression does not have to be final. On a later visit, your attention may move from a bright colour to the composition or texture. Note the names of designs you like and compare them again later. The catalogue provides material to explore; your visual preferences can develop over time.